I'm just in the processing of reading Borsboom's (2006; Psychometrika) provocative article "The attack of the psychometricians." The article abstract is below. As I'm reading, I'm loving a number of statements meant to get the attention of psychologists. Here is the most recent favorite.
Abstract: This paper analyzes the theoretical, pragmatic, and substantive factors that have hampered the integration between psychology and psychometrics. Theoretical factors include the operationalist mode of thinking which is common throughout psychology, the dominance of classical test theory, and the use of “construct validity” as a catch-all category for a range of challenging psychometric problems. Pragmatic factors include the lack of interest in mathematically precise thinking in psychology, inadequate representation of psychometric modeling in major statistics programs, and insufficient mathematical training in the psychological curriculum. Substantive factors relate to the absence of psychological theories that are sufficiently strong to motivate the structure of psychometric models. Following the identification of these problems, a number of promising recent developments are discussed, and suggestions are made to further the integration of psychology and psychometrics.
Technorati Tags: psychology, school psychology, educational psychology, psychometrics, measurement, Psychometrika, neuropsychology
"psychologists have a tendency to endow obsolete techniques with obscure interpretations"
Abstract: This paper analyzes the theoretical, pragmatic, and substantive factors that have hampered the integration between psychology and psychometrics. Theoretical factors include the operationalist mode of thinking which is common throughout psychology, the dominance of classical test theory, and the use of “construct validity” as a catch-all category for a range of challenging psychometric problems. Pragmatic factors include the lack of interest in mathematically precise thinking in psychology, inadequate representation of psychometric modeling in major statistics programs, and insufficient mathematical training in the psychological curriculum. Substantive factors relate to the absence of psychological theories that are sufficiently strong to motivate the structure of psychometric models. Following the identification of these problems, a number of promising recent developments are discussed, and suggestions are made to further the integration of psychology and psychometrics.
Technorati Tags: psychology, school psychology, educational psychology, psychometrics, measurement, Psychometrika, neuropsychology
1 comment:
you can find the article here: http://lib.stat.cmu.edu/~brian/Pmka-Attack-V71-N3/pmka-2006-71.3-425-440-borsboom.pdf
Manfred Mickley, Berlin
Post a Comment