Thursday, November 07, 2024

McGrew on #IQ scores: In what ways are a car engine, a starling bird #murmuration, and #g (general #intelligence) alike..how are they the same?

Kevin McGrew on IQ scores, borrowing from Detterman, 2016, and McGrew et al., 2023)

“General intelligence (represented by a composite IQ score or the factor-analysis derived psychometirc g factor) is a fallible summary statistical (numerical) index of the efficiency of a complex system of dynamically interacting multiple brain networks.  Like the emergent statistical index of horsepower of a car engine, which does not represent a “thing” (a mechanism) in the engine, it reflects the current estimated efficiency of the processing of multiple interacting cognitive abilities and brain networks. It should not be interpreted as being the result of a single brain-based entity or mystical mental energy, as fixed, or reflecting biological/genetic destiny.  The manifest expression of this statistical emergent property index is also influenced by other non-cognitive (conative) traits and temporary states of the individual and current environmental variables” (K. McGrew, 11-07-24)


Question.  In what ways are a car engine, a starling bird murmuration, and general intelligence alike..how are they the same?  See slides and comments below for answer


 

(A starling bird murmuration)

Double click on larger more readable images 


















No comments: